LisaMarie Maher fiction playscript Must Take All

Detail from Haunted House 2 by Christi Nogle, 12″ x 12″, Acrylic on Panel, 2025-26
Must Take All
CAST OF CHARACTERS
ALEX NATALE: Female, Mid-30s. Any race.
DAN NATALE: Male, Mid-30s. Alex’s husband. Any race.
FRAN DELAMOND: Female, 60s, the moderator for the Freecycle Group. Usually white.
MALLORY: Female, late 20s, still prom queen. new mom. Any race.
ERICKA: Female, early 40s, quick to get worked up, one semester of law school. Any race.
BEN: Male, early 30s, Dan’s friend. Any race.
GEORGE: Male, age indeterminate, Dan’s therapist. Any race.
3 TEACHERS/MOMS/NURSES & DOCTORS who will serve as a Greek chorus of sorts
SETTING
Tragically, this play is set on Long Island.
Most scenes take place in the Natale home, Additional scenes or smaller vignettes take place in a teachers’ break room, Ericka’s living room, a coffee shop, a strip club, Mallory’s living room, a hospital, in a car, and on a front porch. These smaller scenes can be suggested with lighting, costumes, or a couple simple set pieces.
A large screen is visible overhead where texts from phones and computer screens are displayed.
Time: Present day-ish
ACT I
Scene 1
A sunroom on the North Shore of Long Island, midwinter. There are a number of potted plants, not all of them thriving. The patio is one of the two rooms the Natales have really invested in; the other is the nursery, which is immaculately decorated, despite its disuse—this should be on an upper level. The kitchen and dining room are to stage right of the patio. Any disembodied voices should come from stage right.
At rise: Alex is at her computer desk, adorned with succulents and other ugly trinkets gifted her by coworkers and former students. She is doomscrolling, as per usual. If possible, we see her moving frenetically and incoherently between tabs—ecommerce, NPR, social media. A ping tells her to return to the local Facebook Freecycle group, where she comes upon an all-caps screed from the moderator of the group. Bingo. She giggles a bit.
ALEX: Babe, she’s on the warpath again
DAN: (offstage) Wait a second, I want to hear this.
ALEX: It’s like, get a life, lady. I mean, I probably should as well. I should turn the notifications off for this stupid group.
DAN: (offstage) Never do that. What would we even talk about?
There’s an awkward pause. He’s said the quiet part out loud—these two have both a ton and nothing to say to each other in the wake of their loss. This is the closest they come to couple’s therapy—shitting on their nearby neighbors as they try to unload and acquire random tchotchkes. Clearing his throat, DAN enters and hands ALEX a cup of herbal tea. She’d been hoping for coffee or vodka, and her face shows it. DAN, oblivious, reads over her shoulder
DAN: “It has come to our attention that a number of members are claiming multiple items, only to put them back up for grabs (or worse, Marketplace!) a week later. That is not the purpose of this group. If you are not sure if you want an item, don’t screw over your fellow free-cyclers. Let it pass. There’s always another juicer or pair of boots.”
Fran joins him, reading her own post from offstage.
DAN/FRAN: “When you take and re-post items, you are making things more confusing for everyone else and sowing distrust and dissension. Knock. It. Off. There is no karmic benefit to reposting someone else’s item. I hate to do this, but I’m going to name names. Sometimes, the only solution is public shaming. So: Becca Brown, Claire Chin, Sara Godsfeld, Shereena Johnson, Aaron Kaplan, Molly Lee, Ericka Mitchells…”
FRAN: “Alexandra Natale”
DAN: (breaking quote) Oh… That’s fucked up. I mean, she must not know…
ALEX: It’s fine.
DAN: No, but that’s different. Obviously, when you reposted the stuff/1
ALEX: /They don’t know the circumstances around/2
DAN: /Right, but maybe she could do some due diligence and/
ALEX: /Dan, come on, she’s a bitter old lady who moderates the Manhasset Freecycle group. Is she supposed to DM everyone individually and go “Hey, hi there, by any chance, did you have a minor tragedy happen or are you just a greedy cunt?” It’s not her job to know/
DAN: /It wasn’t a minor tragedy, Alex. I don’t think there’s any such thing as a minor tragedy, but/
ALEX: /You know what I mean, Daniel.
DAN: Do I?
ALEX: Dan, this was supposed to be fun. Please. Can’t I just have fun and make fun of Fran the Freebie Nazi?
DAN: (resigned) Yeah, sorry. Sorry. I’m…I’m going to message George real quick.
ALEX: (after him as he walks offstage) I’m starting to get jealous of your online therapist
A beat3.
ALEX: (jokingly) Are you having an affair with George?
ALEX: (looking for a reaction) I don’t think you are. Closeted men work harder in the bedroom.
DAN: (re-entering, clearly having ignored ALEX) Alright. All good. Anyway. Any other good stuff on the site?
ALEX: That guy is trying to give away his used bedpan again.
DAN: I still think you should message him. Find out what his deal is.
ALEX: Yeah, because I want to get Internet-murdered
DAN: Anyway. I have to go back to the office for a little while. You going to be okay?
ALEX: Yeah, I’ll hold off on having any psychotic breaks from reality until you get back.
DAN: (Kissing the top of her head, in a whisper) You are my whole world, Alex.
ALEX: (Teasingly, receiving the kiss, also in a whisper) You are bad at geography.
Dan exits, looking over his shoulder at Alex for a moment longer than natural before moving along.
ALEX: (To audience) My husband thinks I’m going to kill myself while he’s at work because our baby died two months ago. What he fails to realize is that 12 years of Catholic school means that, in addition to not really knowing how to dress myself, I am at the lowest statistical risk for suicidality; I’m way more scared of hell than this shit hole.
It also kind of means I don’t know where the baby is. I mean, its body is in a tiny urn on the mantelpiece over there, but we didn’t get around to baptizing it, so…limbo? Purgatory? Direct line to heaven, but, like, B-list heaven? Sources disagree.
I’m inclined to think that a kind and omnipotent God doesn’t penalize babies for failing to tick bureaucratic boxes.
Then again, I’m not sure a kind and omnipotent God gives your kid RSV at daycare and then murders them, either, so, there’s that.
“Why was your 3-month-old at daycare during the most virulent RSV season on record, Alex?” you may well ask.
Well, because this is the US of A, and after my whopping 6 weeks of union-provided maternity leave, wherein I was handed my pay in a lump sum that got taxed beyond belief, I had to go back to watching other people’s snot-nosed little brats in the 3K program. And for some reason, they don’t let you BYOB to the early childhood center.
Anyway, it wasn’t like I was back at work that long before we had to go into the hospital. And then we were there for 15 days. And then we weren’t.
Bereavement leave for the Department of Ed is the day of death and the next 3 calendar days, not including weekends and holidays. Just so you know.
I went back on Day 4, and I lasted until right after recess, when Suzie Chan, who is 3 and ¾, started coughing with abandon in my face. I evidently swore at her virulently and with at least one racial epithet. I was out of body at the time, so I can’t verify what exactly was said.
What I can tell you is that I was offered and then forced to “take some time”—some unpaid time—to really “resettle myself into the new normal.” Because I’m union, unless a kid dies or gets diddled, my job is “safe”, in that they’ve placed me on involuntary leave. Leave suggests coming back. I can’t come back. Not because of the emotional weight but because I know exactly the type of faculty lounge pop psychology going on in there right now
Lights up on one side of the stage, where two women dressed in ill-fitting dress pants and sneakers are mid coffee klatch
TEACHER 1: Oh, my God. It’s absolutely awful. I can’t even begin to imagine.
TEACHER 2: No, I know. I know. I knoooow. I wouldn’t know what to do with myself.
TEACHER 1: And, like, what do you even do with it being your first? Like, do you just try again?
TEACHER 2: I wouldn’t.
TEACHER 1: I mean, the likelihood of it happening twice…
TEACHER 2: The likelihood of it happening once even…
TEACHER 1: Anyway, I wouldn’t even be able to get out of BED in the morning. I totally understand her not wanting to come back.
TEACHER 2: I don’t think it was that she didn’t want to come back.
TEACHER 3: (previously unseen, from behind a copy machine) She’s in the rubber room.
TEACHER 1: They don’t put you in the rubber room for yelling at a kid
TEACHER 3: They do if you call a kid named Suzie “SARSy”
Lights down on the teacher’s lounge
ALEX: So, yeah. I can’t go back to that. We’re kind of sort of comfortable, especially since we no longer have to pay for daycare, so for now I’m a stay at home… mourner.
She heads back to her desk
ALEX: Anyway (Projected as she types) “First Come First Serve. Baby Shoes. Never Worn. Size: Baby. Pick up Eastern Manhasset”
After a moment, we see her delete “Never Worn”
ALEX: Fuck you, Ernest.
Lights Down
ACT I
Scene 2
A living room filled to the brim with bric-a-brac. ERICKA climbs over various items—extra boxes of canned tuna fish, a pair of skates, the cat—trying to get her phone to connect to the WiFi again. A buzz, and she realizes her plans will be thwarted when she takes the call. She sighs, hits “Reject Call”. The phone connects, and she does a little victory dance as she taps out a reply that is seen overhead on the projector. The lines should be said the way one reads to oneself when typing
ERICKA: “Fran, while we all appreciate your (cough) leadership and fortitude, don’t you think this is getting a little micro-managerial? The transactions that occur on this page are person-to-person, and the sizes of families and needs of individuals should be taken into account. I stayed silent when you banned ‘sob stories’ last year because you felt people advocating for themselves and explaining their legitimate claims to items were manipulative and exploitative. When you made the ‘claim, then DM’ rule, I obliged willingly. But now you are calling me out just because 2—two—times that I claimed items for my ailing mother, they turned out to be too small, I reposted them? That’s harassment. That’s discrimination. That’s a violation of the code of conduct that you yourself—”
The phone buzzes again, undoing what she’s just typed. MOM appears in the call screen
ERICKA: Ma, what?
Charlie Brown-esque murmuring on the other side of the phone.
ERICKA: I know it’s Taco Tuesday. It’s Tuesday. There are tacos. You like tacos. When you were here, all you wanted me to do was make tacos. And now that you’re at the home you don’t like their tacos?
Murmur
ERICKA: Of course they’re not authentic Mexican tacos. They’re made by a teenager named Meghan. Mom, I told you. You have to stop calling over nit-picky shit like this. I’m there twice a week, even though I have to take the Belt, which is always jammed, and even though I need to be looking for a job, I am there every Wednesday and Sunday. So, if something’s crawling up your ass, table it until then. I mean, unless something literally is crawling up your ass. They fixed the bedbug thing, right?
Murmured assent
ERICKA: Well, alright then. See? Blue skies ahead.
A click. Back to Facebook
“It was John Locke who once said…”
ACT I
Scene 3
Back in the patio, nighttime. Porch lights behind. DAN is sitting with a particularly dilapidated philodendron in his lap. He is drunk. His phone plays mild porn noises in the background. He whispers into the plant’s leaves.
DAN: Are you… okay? You probably hear that a lot, since I say it to Alex all the time and you live in her office, but seriously, are you okay? You’re looking droopy, buddy. We water you. We give you sunlight. Why so blue? You’re supposed to be (he reads the little tag stuck in the soil) “between a shamrock and an emerald shade”. Well, that’s rude. Saying you should look the same green as another, much less exciting plant. I’d be annoyed too.
He leans his head back, almost to the point of losing his balance.
I’m a mess, Phil. Can I call you Phil? Phil O’ Dendren, right? Anyway, I’m a mess. I mean, I’m not, but Alex is a mess, and that’s not good for me. I told everyone in the bereaved parents’ group about it, about how she’s, like, not connecting physically anymore, and then everyone just gives me the look…
He does the look
And, like, I know she doesn’t owe me sex. No one is saying that. That’s not what this is about. It’s about, like, not connecting, you know? Like, she flinches if I touch her and she won’t do any of the exercises from the workbook they gave us at the hospital, and if I have to send her one more memo about how the next 6-week bereaved parents session starts soon, like…
He loses track of what he’s saying.
And then, Ben? Like, Ben is great and all and he’s trying to be there for me, but he also only wants to be there for me at the strip club out in Commack because he’s trying not to eat too much, and that’s all good except then Alex nags me. She’s all—
ALEX: (enters from offstage and says as Dan mouths)
Why are you going to a strip club in Commack? That’s so dangerous with a 2-drink minimum. There are no public transportation opportunities in Commack. I don’t want to lose you, too. Why don’t you go to a strip club in the city where you can take the train? (She exits)
DAN: And, yes, good point, but we don’t exactly have “Get a lap dance in the city” money, Alex. And also, be more mad that I’m going to a strip club. And, also, like, everyone knows the drinks are watered down. That’s the point. Or one of the points.
He looks at his lap, remembers that he has an audience
Anyway, Ben only wants to talk at Blush, and one time Amber overheard us, so now there’s like, a 50/50 chance that I get my dance for free, and while that’s very nice, I don’t want a “sorry your daughter died” lap dance. But I also don’t want to place demands on Ben, because he’s doing the best he can with his own stuff, right?
So, then I text George, the internet therapist, but then I feel bad because here I am telling Alex, “Get off the computer and go live your life” while I’m tip-tapping away to my imaginary friend the shrink who has impeccable taste. And I feel like my relationship with George is one-sided, which I guess it’s supposed to be, but still…
He assesses
You know, they say talking to plants is good for them? Like, it’s supposed to do…I don’t know, but it’s supposed to cheer them up or something? I’m not really sure how you’re supposed to hear, maybe vibrations or something. I gotta read more. I used to be smart. I mean, I am smart, in a “best guy at the job” type of way, but I used to be Renaissance man smart.
He scritches one of the leaves like it’s a dog’s ear. He’s going to pet the plant the rest of the scene
I was kind of hoping that this was going to be a hard reset. I mean, when I held Amy in my arms, I thought, “I’m going to be better now”. And I think I was. Me and Alex gave her baths and I fed her bottles when Alex was showering, and we snuggled. The first day she went to day care, I cried at my desk, and Alex called me a pussy.
A beat4
She started smiling a week before she got sick. Like, real smiling, with those weird baby gums. She looked like Gollum, but really lovable. Her eyes sparkled. I held her over my head like an airplane, and she giggled and then dropped a long string of spit right into my open mouth. I think she would’ve had my sense of humor. I think she would’ve been tough like Alex.
I mean, she was tough. Once, in the hospital, when Alex was showering, I had been eating something spicy near her, and then I accidentally touched one of her cannulas, because she was eating too, and she was supposed to have the tubes out when she was hitting the bottle. And when I put the cannula back in, she winced from the spices, and then she kinda growled and squirmed. And I said “Scorpion Cannula” in a silly voice, and she giggled, and we went on with our day.
A beat
You know, thinking about it, I think it was grass that can hear, from, like, its underground network. Or, wait, no, grass screams. Right. If you mow the lawn, grass screams.
To plant
Are you feeling a little better?
Lights
ACT I
Scene 4
The next morning. DAN is asleep on the floor on his side, body curled near the plant he was talking to. ALEX walks in from the kitchen in grubby pajamas, grabs a mug off the desk, sniffs, grimaces. She dumps the old coffee into the plant’s pot, then sits down and starts typing as DAN continues to sleep.
ALEX: Fuck.
DAN: (waking) What?!
ALEX: No, the chick who’s coming for the shoes. I thought it was 8PM, not 8AM.
DAN: Oh. What time is it?
ALEX: 7:50. I look like shit.
DAN: You look great. (He rubs his eyes).
ALEX: (pulling a hoodie over her pajamas) Whatever. She’s getting free stuff; she doesn’t get to be choosy.
DAN: How do we still have—
ALEX: My cousin Becca had scheduled them as a Christmas present before/
DAN: /Type A Becca, always good for a/
ALEX: They’re non-returnable, so—
DAN: Yeah, of course. Someone should get some use out of them.
ALEX: Can you go make coffee?
DAN: You’re serving her coffee?
ALEX: No, for me.
DAN: Oh, yeah. Of course.
He exits. Stage right a knocking on the screen door of the patio, which startles ALEX—the patio is on the side of the house. Enter MALLORY in athleisure.
MALLORY: Hey, hi! I’m from the community page? I remembered your house; you gave us some newborn diapers like 3 months ago and it was an absolute lifesaver.
ALEX: Oh, yeah.
MALLORY: I have to say, I am saving so much with this group. Like, I was ready to be in serious hock with Jeremy, and people like you keep us out of the poorhouse. (She laughs; ALEX doesn’t)
MALLORY: Actually, is there any way I can use your bathroom real quick? I’m doing apple cider vinegar, and it’s just running through me at this point
ALEX: (a little taken aback) Oh, yeah, of course. It’s—
MALLORY: I can find it, I’m sure. Thanks!!! (she goes into the house, crossing DAN in the process)
DAN: Is that—
ALEX: Yeah, she needed the bathroom
DAN: Oh.
ALEX: Yeah, I dunno, I—
DAN: —no, I mean, of course
ALEX: Thanks for coffee
DAN: Yeah, hey, listen, that group that meets over at Winthrop—
ALEX: You just woke up. How are you already on this?
DAN: I was just thinking last night/
ALEX: /at the strip club/
DAN: /And I think you’re just burrowing deeper into your shell, and if you’d just/
ALEX: I don’t want to go to that group
DAN: If you just gave it a try
ALEX: I. Don’t. Want. To. Go.
DAN throws up his hands, exasperated, and heads back into the house, crossing MALLORY again
MALLORY: Your house is so twee. Where is baby, by the way? I always love to see what’s coming down the pike.
ALEX: Oh, um.
MALLORY: Is that weird and crazy? That’s weird and crazy. You do not have to show me your baby. I mean, most moms love showing their babies off, but I get it.
ALEX walks out abruptly, in search of the shoes and also deciding what to say or not say. She returns with the shoes but not a decision
MALLORY: Oh. My. God. These are absolutely delicious! (she pretends to “nom” the shoes). I am soooo grateful we are doing neutral colors now, you know? Everything works for all the genders and it is just…it’s the best. I forget, did you guys have a boy or a girl?
Before ALEX can answer
Oh, no! Am I being, like, totally antiquated with that? Are you guys, like, doing the NB thing? I totally support that, you know. I mean, I don’t get it, but I am here for it! I mean, we had a gender reveal for Jeremy, but that was mostly an excuse for a party…and blue frosting. It’s tricky, right?
ALEX: Yeah. It’s tricky. Yeah.
MALLORY: Do you have any coffee?
ALEX: (Before she can stop herself) Girl, do you need coffee?
MALLORY: Oh. My. God. You are funny. It’s hard to find funny people, right? Like, everyone’s so serious just because the planet’s on fire and AI is going to take all of our jobs. Like, lighten up!
ALEX: I think Dan made some coffee. Hold on
MALLORY peruses the patio while ALEX fixes coffee in the next room. She touches some of the knickknacks, moves the mouse to see the background of the laptop is a wedding photo of ALEX and DAN. She knocks over a plant and rights it, kicking dirt behind. ALEX returns.
MALLORY: I am so into this greenery, girl boss. And not, like, having pictures of the baby everywhere. Good for you. You know, we have a moms group that meets Saturday mornings over at Tamper Tantrum, the coffee shop over on Northern? Well, ‘group’ is lofty. There’s three of us. But Monica is absolutely toxic, and you would be, like, the best balance ever. You’ve got to come. Please
ALEX: Oh, I…
MALLORY: Amazing. You are so level-headed. It’s going to be great. (She takes a sip, immediately scowls, puts it on ALEX’s desk.) I’ll send you the deets.
ALEX: Oh, um, great!
MALLORY: Oh sh— Ocean. I have to get going. I told hubby I’d be right back. He should know by now that’s a lie, but still. See you Saturday
She hugs ALEX, who immediately stiffens, then exits. DAN pops his head out with a shit-eating grin.
DAN: A mommy’s group? My wife is going to a mommy’s group?
ALEX: I froze.
DAN: No, I’m ecstatic. This is going to be amazing.
ALEX: Dan, I’m not actually going to go
DAN: Oh, you have to
ALEX: That’s deeply fucked up
DAN: One of two things is going to happen, Alex. Either this is going to be super good and healing for you, or it will be an absolute shit show and we can laugh about it and that will be good for us.
ALEX: Dan, I can’t go to a mommies group. They’re going to ask about being a mommy.
DAN: I would bet any amount they won’t. Those women want to hear themselves talk. You just have to sip a macchiato and nod. Alex, this could be really good.
ALEX: I’ll (a ping) oh Jesus Christ.
DAN: …
ALEX: It’s Mallory. She tagged me in a post. She’s referring to me as her new bestie. Okay, yeah, I’ll go.
ACT I
Scene 5
the Mommy’s group. The coffee shop should be a needlessly hip coffee shop on Long Island. The moms are taking up way too much space around a table. Seating ranges from bench and barstool to bean bag and sit-upon.
MOM 1: And I just told the doctor, “Listen, I’ve seen healthy poop. That ain’t it”
MOM 2: I was just like that with my first. I promise it’s all normal. I mean. Did you take any…I know it sounds crazy, but did you take pictures
MOM 1: Here
Mom 1 shows Mom 2 a carousel of poop photos on her phone, swiping aggressively
MOM 2: Yeah, no, that’s normal
MOM 1: But there’s red in it! I mean, that is almost definitely—
MOM 3: It’s beets.
MOM 1: What?
MOM 3: You posted a pureed beet recipe on Pinterest the other day, you moron
MOM 1: Oh my god, I feel so silly
MOM 3: Don’t worry. Tim did, like, a little baby burp puke one time, and I convinced myself it was pyloric stenosis
MOM 1: Okay, so I had a question about that, too. I was at PM Pediatrics and—
Enter MALLORY and ALEX:
MALLORY: Eww. Stop going there. I dated a PA who worked at an urgent care, and, like, they’re just trying to get you in and out
MOM 1: I can’t help if Willow only gets sick after 5 PM
MOM 3: (muttering) I mean, if you have a $50 copay to blow, why not? God bless…
MALLORY: Guys, this is Alex. She was an absolute lifesaver on freecycle, and she’s just an absolute riot.
ALEX waves feebly amidst the various iterations of “hi”
MOM 2: Mal, I hate you. How are you so skinny already?
MALLORY: I’m not, babe, I’m just in my tailoring era.
Laughter all around. ALEX stares blankly.
Oh, my, God, I’m the worst. Alex, sit anywhere. What do you want? I’m going to get you a matcha.
ALEX: (sitting at an unoccupied edge of a couch) Great
MOM 1: So, Ally
ALEX: Alex
MOM 1: Alex. Tell us about your L.O.
ALEX: My…
MOM 1: Little One.
ALEX: Oh. Um. Well. I/
MOM 2: Holy shit!
MOM 1/ALEX: What?!
MOM 2: Connor just rolled over! I have the little, like, camera thing on the baby monitor linked to my phone, and he just rolled over by himself! Oh my God!!
MOM 3: Yeah, they do that.
MOM 2: (on the phone) Babe. Babe. The baby just rolled over. I know! Okay, I need you to, like, make sure none of his blankies or stuffies or anything are anywhere near him.
MOM 1: (mouthing) Blankies!
MOM 2: No, I know, I’m crazy. But I’m a loving kind of crazy, which is why you tolerate me
MOM 3: (to MOM 1) Okay, listen, don’t pounce on her.
MALLORY returns with two cumbersome mugs, passing one to ALEX and then sitting cross-legged on an easy chair.
MALLORY: Are we pouncing again? I love it!
MOM 1: I’m just saying—what are you doing putting soft goods in the crib?! I still think it’s too early to even put your little man in a crib, but are you courting SIDS?
MOM 2: It’s a stuffy and a thin crochet thing my grandmother made for him. He’s not—
MOM 1: You don’t know that!
MOM 3: Alright, listen, one of our big rules is/
MOM 1: /I know, “throw glitter, not shade”, but/
MOM 3: /No, “good for her, not for me”/
MOM 1: /But it’s not good for her. It’s not good for him! /
MOM 3: /You have got to take a breath.
MALLORY: You got like this with the co-sleeping thing, too. This isn’t, like, the fucking Bible. No one is rolling over on their baby. You act like everyone’s mere moments away from killing their kids, when, for centuries, much worse parents have gotten their kids to adulthood.
MOM 1: Okay, but it’s the inattentiveness. I mean, okay, okay, maybe this is just PTSD because of that time Willow had her brush with death/
MOM 2: (to ALEX): /Her daughter almost caught Measles from an unvaccinated 7-year-old at the pediatrician and had to get some shots/
MOM 1: A TON of SHOTS, MIND YOU. Literally IVIG. But I was saying, I realized in that moment that every moment with our little ones is precious, and I just can’t believe you’re going to be asleep at the wheel like this.
ALEX: (quietly) I mean, she’s not, though.
MOM 1: What?
ALEX: She saw the baby rolling from her phone. Her baby monitor is connected to her phone. She’s obviously attentive.
MOM 1: Okay, listen. I don’t need anything from Mall’s new friend. How would you feel if YOUR baby almost died?
ALEX: Fine.
MOM 1: What?
ALEX: Fine.
MALLORY: Alex, come on, that’s a little….
ALEX: ‘Almost died’ sounds amazing. I would give my right tit for ‘almost died’. ‘Almost died’ is ‘survived’.
MOM 1: You’re deeply fucked up. We have no idea what the long-term impacts of/
ALEX: She’s going to be fine. Jesus. I taught 3K. Parents dropped kids on their heads and did meth, and the kids were still fine. Or, at least, they weren’t dead. They were fine. Kids are always fine unless they’re dead. And even then, I guess they’re fine too. Depending on your definition of fine.
Having a kid is entropic. It’s almost all out of your control, you know? If your kid’s autistic, they are autistic, and no amount of vaccinating or not cuddling or having itchy-old egg cells did that. It’s just what it is. Same with speech delays, same with cerebral palsy—it’s all fucking random, and whether you make organic purees and have them freebase Bach or kick the screen time up to 11 and throw ‘em a Big Mac, it comes out in the wash.
A beat. The other moms stare, aghast.
That’s not true, obviously. They’re all going to be absolutely fucked up. We trashed the generation before them so hard, with the No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top and all those other “everyone gets a prize” schemes that now the pendulum is swung back, and everyone has to be a violin prodigy and trilingual and Division 1 in water polo before they’re in kindergarten or they’re “hopeless,” so we’re cramming all these computer programs down their throat and freaking out if they don’t read in utero, and then we’re shocked when they’re all stressed and depressed and manic all the time. And then we’re writing all these kid-friendly books on Climate Change and Nuclear Proliferation and AI and hoping that they don’t learn the vocabulary word “cataclysm” before we chuck all these problems at them and feast on the carcass of Social Security. So, that’s neat. It’s probably good that they all need to learn water polo, because they’re going to have to tread water to keep living on this shitheap of an island, am I right?
So sorry. You’re right. It is a tragedy that your kid only almost died, because she’s going to have to deal with all this shit, and mine only had to make it through the first 98 days.
ALEX, without waiting for a reaction, walks out, mug in hand. MALLORY starts to chase after her before explaining:
MALLORY: We carpooled, so…
ACT I
Scene 6
DAN and BEN, several watered-down drinks in, at the strip club.
DAN: I miss arguing.
BEN: I’ll argue with you, man. We just argued. You think those are Amber’s real breasts, and I think you’re hopelessly naïve
DAN: That’s not what I mean.
BEN: You don’t think those are her real breasts?
DAN: No, they definitely are. Implants have that, like, wigglyness of those water things you get at the aquarium gift shop, you know what I mean?
BEN: Oh, shit, yeah. Wait, what are those things called?
DAN: They’re called “the water thing from the gift shop”
BEN: They absolutely have a real name. I’m going to look it up.
(He starts to Google, and will continue to look at his phone for the rest of DAN’S spiel)
DAN: Anyway, that’s not arguing
BEN: Yes, it is
DAN: No, it isn’t
BEN: Look, if I argue with you, I must take a contrary position
DAN: You are not quoting Monty Python at me at the strip club
BEN: But this is what makes our friendship beautiful.
DAN: Shut up. I am baring my soul to you. What was I saying?
BEN: You and Alex don’t argue anymore because you’re so maritally entwined in solidarity following your shared trauma
DAN: Right. Wait, what? No. No. What I was saying is I miss the petty arguments that would ruin my day at work, and then I’d come home, and we’d work it out and have, like, pretty okay sex. And it’d be this itty-bitty psycho drama, but everything was relatively safe.
BEN: I have literally no idea what you’re talking about.
DAN: I mean, like, okay. Here’s one. There was one day when Alex was in the shower, and I really needed the bathroom. Like, really, really needed it. Like, the Wednesday after Taco Tuesday. And we only have one bathroom, so we don’t have options here. But I figured I’d be a gentleman and leave the door cracked open to, dissipate the olfactory experience, if you will. And, like, I know flushing changes the water temperature, so I asked, and she said “fine”, but, like, in a way that was not fine? Anyway, I took care of it and thought that was the end of it. But, it was NOT the end of it, and my day was a slew of, like, passive-aggressive texts with things like:
ALEX: (in a towel) I get 10 minutes in my day that are totally mine, and I like to be enveloped in hot steam so I can just, like, think. And you came in and left the door wide open, so it was freezing, and dropped the nastiest dump in the world and peaced out. Did you even wash your hands? What the fuck, Dan?
DAN: Of course I washed my hands. And I left the door open to get rid of the smell
ALEX: That’s not how smells work
DAN: What, you’re a smell scientist all of a sudden?
ALEX: No, but I am a grown-ass adult who bought spray for exactly this purpose
DAN: What, the perfume on the tank?
ALEX: When have I ever worn perfume?
DAN: I don’t know. That stuff looks too fancy to be poop spray
ALEX: I don’t want to broadcast that it’s poop spray
DAN: Well, then how was I supposed to know it was poop spray?
ALEX: Because you live here! Anyway, I had to spray it after freezing my ass off in your smelly bathroom!
DAN: Wait, now it’s my bathroom?
ALEX: (fading out) Well, you marked it with your scent, didn’t you?
DAN: And then we’d fume separately and have a tense dinner, and by the end of the day she’d ask me what a smell scientist was, and I’d laugh about the “marking my territory” thing and we’d be okay. But that doesn’t happen anymore. Now, if I do something annoying or screw up and forget to pick up milk, she just says…nothing. No reaction. I might as well not be there. And when I get snippy at her because she left stuff all over the place even though she’s home all day, or forgot to pay the Internet bill or whatever, she just apologizes. Or ignores it.
BEN: Maybe there’s just nothing else to fight over?
DAN: I tested it, you know.
BEN: You took another shit while she was showering? That’s messed up
DAN: No, of course not. I can’t summon a bowel movement like that. No, I just, last week, I opened the bathroom door and asked if we had any more coffee beans or if I should pick some up. And she said:
ALEX: Check the pantry. I don’t keep a running list
DAN: And that was…it. No follow-up. No texts. I’m a ghost in my own house. Maybe I would be better off just not there
BEN: You’re right
DAN: Umm
BEN: It is just called a water wiggler/
DAN: /Are you for real?
BEN: /It feels like there should be a better name for/
DAN: /I’m baring my soul to you and/
BEN: /this thing you and Alex are going through.
DAN: Oh.
BEN: I don’t think you miss arguing. I think you miss who you were back before the thing happened. I think that probably you thought if you read the books and went to group and texted your therapist, you could speed run grief. But you can’t. It’s not some concrete thing that you can just put in a box, and it’s not something fluid that you can move through. Grief’s a colloid, man. It’s Jell-O. It’s like—
DAN: Don’t you dare
BEN: (insistently) It’s like a water wiggler, and if you try to force it one way or the other, it’s going to explode on the back of a school bus. Okay, the metaphor got away from me, but this is what it is. You have to let yourself grieve, like, the marriage you had before Amy died and all the plans you had and all the ways in which you used to be weightless, because that stuff is gone. And you’ll keep being alive, and you’ll have moments of joy, but everything from here has the color saturation turned down a little bit, and it’s not fair, and none of us can do anything to make that better. It just is. And I’m sorry.
Both men sit with this for a minute. BEN is almost as shocked by his sudden profundity as DAN.
DAN: Hey, thanks.
BEN: Of course
DAN: Can I break our “No hugging in the strip club” rule
BEN: Yeah, that’s fine. Denise isn’t even working tonight, anyway.
They loop arms over each other as the lights fade out.
ACT I
Scene 7
MALLORY’S Living room, in the fallout of scene 5. ALEX is sitting on MALLORY’s couch, head between her legs. MALLORY is tidying a non-existent mess, trying not to spiral by doling out more and more aggressive suburban-mom niceties.
MALLORY: I am so, so sorry about the mess. You know how it is—you start to act like a human, and then the baby cries and then it gets away from you and— oh. Oops
ALEX: (from between her legs) It’s fine
MALLORY: Would it help you if I told you I am drowning? Like, absolutely cannot get on top of anything. Monica said I was losing weight, but I just fucking forget to eat. Did you ever forget to eat?
ALEX: No
MALLORY: Makes sense. But, like, I can’t even get through basic functions. And I’ve hit an absolute wall with the hubs. Like, I thought once I had the baby, I would be like those women on TikTok—or, Reels, I don’t actually have TikTok, I just have a friends who send me TikToks—and I could braise a roast in florals while we do alphabet games. But that’s not it at all. I only wear athleisure; I don’t suddenly know how to cook and, he does NOTHING. He’s so boring and keeps me so busy at the same time. And I feel so stupid all the time. Like, I can’t tell what’s an emergency and what’s just, like, a thing, and now I have to start these applications for kindergarten and…oh, shit, here it is (she produces a vape, then continues to explain) This is a calming pen—it’s all-natural and is meant to, like, do a soft-reset on your senses. Totally homeopathic, nothing hits your bloodstream, just a nice little moment of Zen.
ALEX: No thanks. (waves it off, head still between legs)
MALLORY: I feel absolutely awful about how all that went down. I should have asked. I mean, you also probably should have mentioned at some point that your kid is dead, but still, I probably should have, like, had a longer conversation with you before asking you to Mom’s group. It can get a little intense. I feel awful, though. I need to give you something. Can I give you—something?
ALEX: (dryly) Scotch
MALLORY: I have alcohol-free rosé?
ALEX: I’m good. I think I’m actually going to head out in a minute. I just need to sit.
MALLORY: Okay
She continues to scurry around—now, she both needs to be polite and not wanting her shiny new friend to leave. It hits her—
I’ll make my Ricky-Tequila-Tavis
ALEX: …
MALLORY: I bartended for a summer on a party cruise boat—one of those things that kind of just circle the Great South Bay while people get hammered? And me and the other girls, we’d come up with more and more ridiculous drinks to get people to give us tips, and I came up with the Ricky-Tequila-Tavi, which is a Lime Ricky but you add tequila too, and it messes you up like a Long Island Iced Tea, but it tastes amazing. I’ll make us a couple.
ALEX: Oh, you don’t have to… (but she already is. ALEX fiddles with her hands, takes out her phone, considering texting DAN, doesn’t. MALLORY re-enters with two wine glasses full of red liquid)
ALEX: That was fast!
MALLORY: You have no idea. Prost!
ALEX: Oh, um, thanks.
Pass the time somehow. Stagehand magic should make more empty/half empty glasses appear. Maybe a wine bottle.
ALEX: (laughing) So, have I ruined the Mom’s Group permanently?
MALLORY: Oh, no. Don’t get it twisted. You are going to be a unifying force for all time. Whenever something gets weird with those bitches, they are going to be like “Oh my God, remember when Mallory brought that crazy lady with the dead baby to group?” and then everyone will tell increasingly convoluted stories about you, and it will be, like, a balm. And I’ll vaguely stand up for you, but not in, like, a meaningful way.
ALEX: That sounds…very accurate.
MALLORY: I’ve been in a lot of female homosocial groupings. Kickboxing cliques. Bridal party besties. One time, an MLM. Would it surprise you to know I was a cheerleader in high school AND college?
ALEX: It would not.
MALLORY: I try very, very hard to engage in female solidarity. It’s unsatisfying.
ALEX: Sounds like it.
MALLORY: But, also, like, I have to. I married Rick out of high school; and you can’t be that cliché and then turn your back on feminism, or it becomes a whole thing, you know? What about you? Have any gal pals?
ALEX: Um. I mean. Not really. No. I have a sister
MALLORY: That doesn’t count.
ALEX: And Dan has a sister
MALLORY: That DEFINITELY doesn’t count.
ALEX: Then, yeah, no. I mean, I had some coworkers, but that’s now, like, just random texts of GIFs and jokes about how lucky I am not to be there while the superintendent is visiting.
MALLORY: Gross
ALEX: Right. Like, they mean well, but also…
ERICKA: (from offstage) Knock, knock!
MALLORY: What the—
ERICKA: I’m here for the, um, squatty potty thing? I’m from the Facebook group? We confirmed yesterday, and I sent, like, a bunch of messages to check the time, but I didn’t get a response, so I figured I’d come over.
MALLORY: Shit (to ERICKA) Oh, of course! Come in!
MALLORY goes back into hostess mode, but way less steady on her feet.
Hi!!!
ERICKA: Sorry, am I interrupting something? I could always come back
MALLORY: No! No, no, no. No! I’ll go find it. It’s probably in the basement. You guys just sit and chat. (Exiting)
ERICKA: Hi.
ALEX: Hey.
A beat.
ERICKA: This is probably weird, but are you also on the Freecycle page?
ALEX: Oh. Um. Yeah. Occasionally.
ERICKA: You got called out by Fascist Fran too! Sorry if that sounds creepy. After she tagged me, I kind of fell down a rabbit hole and was trying to figure out what high crimes and misdemeanors everyone was guilty of.
ALEX: Oh, yeah, that makes sense.
ERICKA: Fran’s a cunt.
Alex half nods in agreement
And a hypocrite. Did you see that major dump she just posted? It’s like, no joke, 70 items of men’s clothing and then she puts ‘Must Take All’, like, bitch, who needs all that old man clothing? Are we doing a high school production of “Grumpy Old Men?” Seriously.
ALEX: Huh. That is weird. (Drunk ALEX is a little more intrigued than sober ALEX would be.)
ERICKA: I mean, damn, bitch, like, sorry your itchy-old asshole husband left you or whatever, but bring that shit to Goodwill. Ain’t nobody here want that.
ALEX: I mean, more likely he died.
ERICKA: That’s dark as hell. I like you.
ALEX: I just mean, people like to cleanse their homes after a death, and make sure it gets put to good use, blah blah blah.
ERICKA: That’s what you did after your kid died?
ALEX: Excuse me?
ERICKA: Like I said, I fell down a rabbit hole. Anyway, this is instructive. I’m just waiting for my mom to croak so I can stop running around like a lunatic and feeling guilty all the time that I can’t have her in, like, a nice place but also can’t handle her on my own.
ALEX: That must be hard.
ERICKA: It is.
MALLORY re-enters
MALLORY: I just had to wipe it down
ERICKA: Ew
MALLORY: No, it got dusty. I swear, I would NOT pass along anything that had urine on it.
ALEX: Very reassuring
ERICKA: Well, thanks. My mom’s in a home, and half the time they give her stuff that makes her shit too much and then other half of the time she’s constipated, so…
MALLORY: Glad it could be of use. My husband got it for me as a gag gift and it’s a little embarrassing.
ERICKA: You girls seem like you like to party. I’m shocked that you’d get embarrassed over this. But, your loss is my gain, right? Or my mom’s, I guess. Or whatever sad orderly has to watch her.
MALLORY: Well, thanks for taking it off my hands. Bye now!
ALEX: Hey, did you want one of these drinks?
MALLORY: Oh, well, I don’t know if…
ERICKA: Oh, my god, absolutely. What are these, Shirley Temples that fuck you up?
MALLORY: Well…
ALEX: Ricky Tequila Tavis
ERICKA: (sitting on the couch between MALLORY and ALEX, squatty potty still under arm) Amazing name. Do you chase it with Mongoose malt liquor?
MALLORY: That’s actually kind of brilliant.
ERICKA: I have a knack when it comes to wordplay and booze. One time…
Lights fade as Ericka recounts an insane story.
ACT I
Scene 8
The sunroom. Later that night. ALEX is asleep on the futon. DAN comes in from the outdoor entrance, tiptoeing unsuccessfully. Both are not in good shape. The hangover has not yet arrived, but it’s looming. DAN inadvertently sits on ALEX.
DAN: Oh, shit!
ALEX: Get. Off.
DAN: Honey, oh my God. I am so sorry. Why aren’t you in bed?
ALEX: Why aren’t YOU in bed?
DAN: I just got in
ALEX: What, it was half-off bikinis over there? (ALEX sits up, pats for DAN to sit next to her)
DAN: No, Ben and I just really got to talking.
ALEX: Oh. Well, that’s nice.
DAN: Actually, one of the things I was saying to him was, like, you know what we—you and I—haven’t done in a while?
ALEX: Oh. Yeah.
What follows is a series of bizarre stretches, first standing full-body stretches, then specifically her mouth. She ties her hair up in a ponytail, turns to face DAN, and squats down, assuming the position
DAN: What the fuck, no! Well, I mean, maybe later. But no, I meant just, like, talk. About what comes next.
ALEX: You teed that up for me.
DAN: No, stop doing the “jokes as defense mechanism” thing. We haven’t talked since Amy’s funeral about when we’re going to, you know…
ALEX gestures “go on”
When we’re going to think about maybe growing our family again.
ALEX: No.
DAN: I’m not saying now. I’m just saying, like, a sense of a sense of what we both want. Like, how many, maybe a timeline. And if it’s too soon, like, that’s okay. I just want to know that maybe we’re going to think about having that conversation in the nearer future. So we’re not stuck in stasis forever.
ALEX: I’m good.
DAN: What does THAT mean?
ALEX: I’m good. I’m not interested in growing anything. I’m fine as is. Good talk
DAN: Now hold on a minute—
ALEX: You asked me what I wanted. I don’t want anything.
DAN: But that’s not how this works.
ALEX: Why not?
DAN: Because that wasn’t a conversation. That was you making a unilateral decision that totally upends, like, all the things we used to talk about.
ALEX shrugs
What happened to us moving into a bigger house in a couple of years, when kid #2 of 3 came along? What happened to us socking away for a place the next town over to get into a better district? What happened to family passes at Sesame Place since you can go for free as a teacher and I can go for free as a reservist, and we just lie to the kids about Sesame Place being Disney until they’re in their 40s? We had plans, Alex. I want updates. I want us to talk late into the night about all the things we’re going to do.
ALEX: How are you asking me what happened? All you do is talk about what happened, and now you’re asking me what happened? ‘It’ happened, Dan.
DAN: I’m not talking about now. I’m talking about when.
ALEX: Never
DAN: Hey, I understand if you don’t want to have another one biologically. Ashlee in group/
ALEX: /Jesus/
DAN: /was saying that there’s, like, trauma she carries in her body, and I totally get that. But we could absolutely afford to adopt/
ALEX: No
DAN: Or something! Get a dog. I don’t know. Give me something.
ALEX: The worst-case scenario—that’s your something. The thing you keep in your pocket for when shit gets bad—“Well, at least the baby didn’t die”—happened.
And now, I’m expected to keep fucking, what, respirating? Taking 20,000 breaths a day and using 2000 calories and sleeping and rising and eating and shitting and bathing and talking and all of it? Every day? And you want to talk about the future. You want to talk about doing more than that, when we’ve failed the basic biological imperative of “keep offspring alive.” You want to try to do anything, ANYTHING at all, when we’ve failed so tremendously? When every day of the rest of our lives has the footnote “By the way, their daughter died.” Every day. Forever. When there is nothing that either of us can do to erase that from history, you want to talk about trying again? About replacing her? Moving on? Fuck. You.
She starts to exit
DAN: Hey. HEY (There’s a rage he didn’t know was there that builds as he speaks)
Stop walking away from me and deciding when it ends. I decide when it ends. I get a say. I fucking pay for everything and I am doing the work and making the moves and listening to the podcasts and trying endlessly, endlessly, endlessly, to deal with you with compassion and affection and love, and you’re over here acting like just because your tits are leaky, you’re the only one who lost something, when you were fucking ambivalent to begin with.
ALEX: Dan, don’t.
DAN: No. If we’re out here clearing the air, let’s get it all out. You didn’t want her.
ALEX: Don’t say things you can’t take back
DAN: You freaked out when you took that test. You said you weren’t ready.
ALEX: Dan
DAN: And I said I’d support whatever you wanted to do, and you did the thing you always do, the thing that’s fucking ambivalent and middle of the road and indecisive. You couldn’t fucking stomach actually going and having an abortion, because you have some idea about yourself, so you—what? You tried to trigger miscarriages.
ALEX: Dan
DAN: With your medieval, fucking, what? Chewing parsley and OD-ing on vitamin C? And when that didn’t work, you resigned yourself to maternity. You weren’t enthusiastic. You didn’t do the parties or the registry or any of the things women who want it do. It was just another thing you were going to do for us, like the dishes or mowing the lawn or whatever.
Building
And now, fucking, you use this as an excuse to mope around all day licking your wounds and, like, disengaging from everyone and acting like this only affected you and I have to live on my toes, because God forbid I say something that’s going to pile on to Alex, poor Alex, look at Alex persevering in spite of it all. But I am looking at you, Alex. And you’re full of shit.
ALEX walks out. She returns with a baby book, clearly filled with her handwriting. She throws it, open, at DAN’s feet.
ALEX: (almost inaudible) I spend all day, every day, trying not to think about it. Because I know that I did this. I know this is comeuppance, that I was ungrateful and irresolute, and that when I prayed not to be pregnant—not to have to be a mom— I got a delayed response. I brought this on her, on us, on myself. And whatever you may think, I wanted her, and I made her die with my fear and my prayers. And I will never not know that. When I am dead, I will know that I killed our child with my rash horror, with my greed. Every moment I am trying to stay busy so that I can’t think. But it never stops. It never, ever stops, and there is no escaping this. My remorse is a mobius strip. I cannot be forgiven. I cannot be redeemed. And I refuse to inflict that on anyone, or anything else.
So, you can make whatever plans you want. Leave, stay, change out my birth control with Tic Tacs, adopt a ferret. Do whatever you want, Daniel. None of it matters. I am not the thing I was.
She walks out with purpose. He starts to follow, then sits down with the baby book, reading, mouthing as he does.
On the far side of the stage, we see ALEX, in liminal space, phone in hand. The projection reads a group chat to MALLORY and ERICKA
ALEX: Hey, ladies! That was so, so fun this afternoon! I’m definitely paying for it now. But I was thinking, remember how we were, like, spitballing about messing with Fran a little and taking all of those clothes. I think we should do it—claim all that stuff and get inside the mind of the enemy. It could be, like, really funny. I’m free next weekend—LMK!
End of ACT I
ACT II
Scene 1
The sunroom. Mother’s Day. The detritus of Alex taking up residence in there. She’s been sleeping on the couch since the fight in Act I. While the Natale home is not an active warzone, it is a quiet stalemate—these are no longer spouses, but rather roommates who occasionally have sex. The plants are fewer and farther between.
At rise: The sound of the phone buzzing. Projected overhead are a number of well-intentioned, but misguided, Mother’s Day wishes in succession, ranging from “Thinking of you babe!” to “Happy first Mother’s Day” to a Precious Moments-style gif that reads “Even when our babies are no longer with us, they are still our babies and in the arms of our precious virgin mother”. The last should be a short but sweet “Love you” from “Mom”. ALEX, bleary-eyed, scrolls through these.
DAN enters with coffee, much as in ACT I. He also has a card. He kisses ALEX on the forehead as she scrolls.
DAN: Hey
ALEX: Hey. What’s this?
DAN: Oh, umm. It is a card. I don’t know, maybe that’s stupid.
ALEX: No, that was thoughtful. Did Ashlee pick this out?
DAN: She…advised me against picking out the one with Snoopy on it.
ALEX: Dang.
DAN: Okay, so I was totally right.
Dan pulls a second card out of his back pocket
ALEX: This is a superior card.
She gets up to put it on her desk
DAN: Do you have anything you wanted to do today?
ALEX: I was thinking of joining the Québécois, but I realized I don’t speak French, so maybe I’ll just fill out some job applications.
DAN: Okay, if you wanted to go on, like, a walk or something, let me know.
ALEX: That sounds nice.
DAN: Okay!
DAN exits. Light change. ALEX comes downstage. Ensemble members stand in the shadows in a U-formation; they will fill in these parts with demonstrative, almost dress-up-like outfits as the monologue progresses
ALEX: This is what it’s like. You get a text from daycare during center time asking if the baby has asthma. “I don’t know,” you text back, because that wasn’t covered during the whole “Don’t shake the baby/do do skin to skin” video playlist they make you watch at the hospital. Daycare says baby is breathing funny, so you get your assistant principal to cover you, and she has this knowing smile like:
ASSISTANT PRINCIPAL: (bemusedly) New moms…
ALEX: And you pick up the baby from daycare and your doctor’s office is closed for Sukkot, because of course it is, and you Google what Sukkot is in the waiting room of the urgent care, because you feel like you should have known that one. And when the PA finally sees your kid, he says
PHYSICIAN’S ASSISTANT: You must be a new mom. This? This is nothing. Get off the Internet and stop driving yourself nuts
ALEX: In this voice that just says
ALEX/PHYSICIAN’S ASSISTANT: “You are the dumbest bitch that ever lived”
ALEX: So you go home, and you crank up the humidifier and use that tube thing where you suck the snot out of her nose with a straw, and then you wonder if you can do damage to their nasal passages that way, if maybe now she’s struggling to breathe because you inflamed her little nostrils too much, but she’s retracting really hard, gasping for breath. So you call the emergency number from the pediatrician’s office’s voicemail, and he says
PEDIATRICIAN: Y’ello?
ALEX: And you apologize for calling on the high holy, and he appreciates that
PEDIATRICIAN: I appreciate that. What’s up, Mommy?
ALEX: And you describe her symptoms, and he says
PEDIATRICIAN: Get her to the ER. Immediately.
ALEX: And before you hang up, he tells you to go to the one 15 minutes away instead of the one in the same town
PEDIATRICIAN: Because those people? They are med-school fuck-ups. Go to Winthrop
ALEX: So you struggle with the stupid little straps on her car seat and your husband drives, and you sit next to her the whole time, singing, trying to keep the panic out of your voice, because you don’t want to make her more scared, but you can’t think of any lullabies, so you just kind of end up singing whatever comes to mind
Sufjan Stevens “Enchanting Ghost” in background through rest of scene
Tell me what you saw in me
And I’ll try to replicate it with a scene
Mm-mmm
If it troubles you to breathe
Wait a moment; I could change the scenery
Don’t carry on carrying efforts, oh no, oh oh oh oh
Somewhere there’s a room for each of us to grow
And if it pleases you to leave me, just go, oh oh oh oh
Stopping you would stifle your enchanting ghost
And that seems to work and you just, like, yank the whole car seat out when you get to the ER and the security guard sees you, frantic, and asks you to take a mask and in the little hallway, everyone tries to stay away from you and the baby and they take your insurance card and your ID and give you a little badge and put you in a little room where you and the nurse struggle to get the pulse oximeter around her toe, because the stupid feety pajamas will NOT cooperate, but they put on that and take her blood pressure with, like, an adult cuff and take a rectal temp and you’re busy so you can’t really panic. And the doctor brings you into another ER room and goes
DOCTOR: That’s not good.
ALEX: (Gets on the bed, attempts “nursing”) But they tell you they’re going to monitor her, and so, why don’t you go ahead and feed her, and you try to lay on the hospital bed and nurse her but there’s so many wires and it’s so awkward, but you get the nipple in her mouth and she nurses, and then you try to take it out because you think she’s asleep and she SCREAMS and it’s the best sound in the world because you hadn’t realized how quiet she’d been. And that’s when a whole gaggle of doctors—a mob of doctors, a flock, a murder—come in and say
DOCTORS: (in unison) We’re going to admit her
ALEX: And you stay on the bed with her, and her car seat is in the corner of the bed, and they wheel you both into the elevator and upstairs, to the pediatric wing where there are 12 year olds with cancer and kids with broken bones and other wheezy babies, and they stick you in a room and now other medical professionals are introducing themselves and you don’t track anyone’s name, but they’re all “checking in” and they are in and out and she keeps pulling the oxygen tubes out of her little nose and kicking off the pulse ox and you’re supposed to put her diapers on a little scale on the counter and, I don’t know, maybe 4 hours later, they tell you that she’s not responding to the treatment, so, not to worry, but we’re going to move her into the PICU—the pick you—to put her on a BiPap, just until she gets better.
NURSE 1: Just until she gets better
ALEX: But BiPap moves air too hard for her to swallow liquids—she might aspirate—so now you can’t feed her anymore, and they shove a feeding tube down her, and she gets pissed off at that and the IV and starts yanking everything, and there’s blood, and then they wrap her tiny fist in a diaper so that she can’t get at anything. And you are there for days, just talking to her and apologizing. And so many people come in
As she narrates, they pass. If you wanted to throw in the Village People or some other equally absurd array of characters, that’d be fine.
There’s the play therapist and the volunteer with the therapy dog—like, a baby doesn’t need a therapy dog—and social workers and priests and just—everyone. And you’re sleeping on a chair for short intervals while you chat with respiratory therapists and residents and nurses and you’re being polite to everyone, because that’s how you were raised. And then, like a miracle, she can go off the BiPap, and you’re back in the normal pediatric wing. And yes, you are rank because you’ve only changed your clothes a couple of times and haven’t been brushing your teeth regularly. You went home once, when your mom stood vigil, but it’s gross. And you’re eating the hospital food, which is, you know, fine; they’re doing the best they can. And you hoard coffee whenever the coffee cart comes out in the morning. And then, Day 10, they send you home!
And it’s amazing. They send you with a nebulizer and saline and albuterol and all kinds of instructions, and you’ve never been so happy for the nuisance. And that girl eats. She cannot get enough breast milk. She’s so happy. And a day later, the hospital calls to ask if you’re doing okay, and you say yes, just, she’s flaring her nostrils a lot, and they say come back. And you throw a bunch of sweats and underwear in a bag, because now you’ve learned.
And so, you go back, and the nurses, now they know you guys, so they dote
NURSES: Amy!
ALEX: And you’re back on BiPap, but you can survive it, because you’ve done this. And on, like, the third day, one of the nurses says
NURSE 1: Why don’t you go take a walk? Get a cup of coffee or something? There’s a Starbucks around the corner. No one should be in here this many hours.
ALEX: And so, you do. You get a chai latte. And you walk back to the room, and you can’t get in. You’ve never seen so many doctors, and they’re all surrounding the little incubator hospital bed thing that your kid is in, and one of the nurses tells you to go sit in the hallway. So you do. And your husband rushes in, and he sits next to you, because they called him at work and he did 80 the whole way, and you both sit, and eventually, someone, who knows who, comes out, and the words don’t make sense, and your husband sobs, and you, well, you must understand it eventually because you vomit into your own hands.
The vomiting isn’t shown, but one of the ensemble should pass directly in front of her with a mop
ALEX: And you apologize and get cleaned up, and they ask you if you want to hold her, and you say
DAN/ALEX: Yes/ No
ALEX: And then, eventually, they give you a folder and tell you to go home. And you can’t, because you’re definitely forgetting something, so you rifle through your bags and look all over the room and search because there’s something you’re supposed to bring home.
Everyone looks at her, waiting for her to realize…
Oh. Right.
Lights down.
ACT II
Scene 2
MALLORY’s living room. All three women in the same pose—Irish coffee in one hand, phone in the other, conspiring.
ERICKA: Okay, so I was first to comment “Want” on that witch’s post. She said you were first, Mallory, and that I could “que upon if something goes awry”
MALLORY: Right, and then she messaged me to say that the first poster—you—had fallen through, and I was welcome to pop by at a “reasonable hour.” I’m waiting to hear from her what she thinks a reasonable hour is. God, she’s awful.
ALEX: That’s kind of the point, though, right? We need her to know we know she’s awful, and that she’s got to back off. So, all three of us will confront her about her nonsense, and she’ll have a come-to-Jesus moment.
MALLORY: Or she’ll keep being awful, but at least we’ll have tried!
ERICKA: We could always cold-clock her
ALEX/MALLORY: Jesus, Ericka!
ERICKA: It was a joke!
ALEX: Still…
A ping
MALLORY: It’s her! She said to come now. Fuck, I’m not… I’m not good to drive. I just tested my breast milk and—
ERICKA: What are you talking about?
MALLORY: They’re these little strips and you just kind of dip it in and mine is WAY above the blood alcohol level. I am not metabolizing booze the way I used to.
ERICKA: That’s insane
ALEX: No, it’s legit. If you can drive, you can nurse, and vice-versa.
ERICKA: And my car has an Intoxalock, so…
ALEX: Just get in mine. What’s the address?
MALLORY: It’s 18 Bumblebee Street, off the Northern
ERICKA: How is even her address annoying?
MALLORY: Wait, what about Jeremy? I’m not super comfortable with someone else driving my car and we can’t leave him here. Rick won’t be back for at least another hour.
ALEX: I have a carseat. Get him and let’s go.
MALLORY: Oh! Great!
ALEX leaves ahead of ERICKA and MALLORY, who shoot each other a knowing look.
ACT II
Scene 3
Car interior. ALEX alternates between fiddling with the radio and checking the rear-view mirror. After a while of this:
ALEX: You doing okay back there, Jeremy? You comfortable? Warm enough?
A beat
Your mom’s going to be right back, okay? I know this is kind of weird, but that’s only because we didn’t totally think this plan through. Your mom’s got mommy brain, and I’m all kinds of messed up. Not sure what Ericka’s deal is, but the point is we probably could have taken a few more minutes to flesh out “what do we want out of taking old man clothes from Fran?”, but we didn’t, so here we are.
A beat
Jeremy’s kind of a stupid name. No offense, I know you didn’t name yourself. Still. Not sure I could take a Jeremy seriously. “Jeremy for Congress.” “Dr. Jeremy, what did those lab results find?” “I’m not worried. Secretary of State Jeremy is in peace talks with the Russians.”
A beat
And your mom sure was ready to leave you with me, a stranger. Then again, I drove your mom, a stranger, to a trolling expedition with another stranger and then offered to watch her kid so she could troll unencumbered, so who am I to throw stones, right?
A beat
You’re sounding a little wheezy there, bud, you okay? (she turns) Probably just hay fever; this time of year is absolutely brutal. You know why? It’s because there aren’t enough female trees to accept all the pollen from the male trees. Robert Moses got a cut-rate deal on male trees in the ‘50s when he was building the Long Island Expressway, and now none of us can breathe out of our noses for half the year. I learned that at a seminar in college. I can’t remember where I had my first kiss with my husband, but I remember that. The brain is really weird, Jeremy. I hope by the time you’re older—
Gunshot offstage. ERICKA and MALLORY run back toward the car in a frenzy
ALEX: What the fuck?
MALLORY: Language!
ALEX: Was that a—
ERICKA: Yes! Drive.
ALEX: Okay, well buckle up first/
ERICKA/MALLORY: Are you serious?! Go!
Lights and the sound of car wheels squealing.
ACT II
Scene 4
Sunroom. DAN is tapping on his phone. BEN looms over his shoulder. GEORGE’s responses should be projected above, but the voice must remain offstage.
DAN: Hey, George, I hope all is well. I saw the game the other day. Looks like those Pirates of yours are off to a great start.
GEORGE: Daniel, you do not have to do the niceties every time you message me. What’s on your mind today?
DAN: I actually have a question for a friend
GEORGE: Daniel
DAN: No, really, an actual friend. Not me. I’m not masking or whatever it is you call it.
GEORGE: Daniel, I cannot provide advice for someone who is not my patient.
BEN: Man, just say it’s you.
DAN: Fine. Okay. I wanted to ask you about a problem I am having with, um, intimacy?
GEORGE: Go for it.
DAN: Okay, um, so, when I am about to get intimate with a partner, I find myself getting teary-eyed? Like, I’m still aroused, but also my eyes keep watering?
GEORGE: Well, Daniel, that’s absolutely nothing to be ashamed of. I mean, of course you’re going to have conflicting and complicated emotions around sex with your wife. Sex always means more than one thing, and the intimacy intertwines with all the things it stands for –your relationship, your needs, your loss. It makes perfect sense that your body is going to react before your brain has a chance to catch up. I wouldn’t be too worried.
BEN: That doesn’t help! Tell him it’s with all kinds of different ladies.
DAN: Man, what? I’m obviously not getting with all types of different ladies
BEN: You could be
DAN: George and I have a good, like, rapport. I’m not going to pretend I’m having an affair just to figure out why you cry when you get hard
BEN: Why does it matter? He’s gotta help you even if he thinks you’re a scumbag
DAN: Why can’t you just Google it? Or get your own therapist?
BEN: I did Google it. It said I might have cancer.
DAN: Dude.
BEN: Dude.
DAN: (Sigh) Fine (To GEORGE, reading as he types) I also have this experience when I am in intimate scenarios without Alex
As DAN reads this last text, ALEX, MALLORY (carrying Jeremy’s car seat), and ERICKA enter in a flurry.
DAN/ALEX: Shit!
ALEX: Wait, what?
DAN: I’m talking to George. Don’t worry about it.
ALEX: But I heard ‘Alex’. You were talking about me. Give me the phone
DAN: No!
ALEX: Fine. Can you guys leave? We have to deal with something.
DAN starts to protest, but gets the “I didn’t insist on seeing your phone” look and ushers BEN into the kitchen.
ALEX: Alright, what the fuck was that?
MALLORY: Language!
ERICKA: Well, I mean, it’s pretty normal to talk to a therapist about your sex life—
ALEX: Not that! The shooting and the running and the hyperventilating in the car.
MALLORY: We have about as much information as you do.
ERICKA: Bitch didn’t even open the door
MALLORY: I texted, and rang the doorbell, and nothing. But there were, like, a bunch of garbage bags on the porch and they looked clean, so I thought maybe she just left the clothes there, and so Ericka and I each opened a bag
ERICKA: It was NOT clothing. It was straight up trash and it was gross, and if Mallory didn’t have a wet wipe in her pocket—
MALLORY: So we’re tying the bags back up and all of a sudden there’s a pop and the window on the other side of the porch just— shatters
ERICKA: And we did not wait around to find out what kind of “Stand Your Ground” bullshit we’d gotten ourselves into.
MALLORY: There’s nothing on “Next Door” or “Patch” or “Citizen” about it, which is insane, because how often are there just, like, shots fired in Port Washington
ERICKA: I think it’s technically Sans Point
MALLORY/ALEX: Ericka!
ERICKA: Just, like, let’s get our story straight. I did a semester of law school. We need to be clear about our communal experience
ALEX: For what?
ERICKA: For the inevitable police report. Everyone and their second cousin has a camera on their house nowadays. You don’t think there are, like, ten different calls into the cops as we speak, with our dumb asses running off the porch like we were in the middle of breaking and entering? And Alex’s license plate just, like, chilling there? We’re looking at unlawful trespass, endangering a minor, who knows what else.
MALLORY: Shit!
ALEX: I feel like we’re maybe blowing this out of proportion a little/
MALLORY: /my parole officer is going to kill me.
ERICKA/ALEX: What?
MALLORY: Nothing.
ALEX: What parole officer, Mallory?
A beat, shuffling through the diaper bag, hands Jeremy a binkie
MALLORY: I had a little… hiccup a couple of years ago with some of the, like, Herbalife stuff. It wasn’t a huge deal, but there was an altercation with the girl upstream from me and things got a little out of hand.
ERICKA: How out of hand?
MALLORY: I set fire to the inventory in her garage. But, it was a detached garage and no one got hurt and the product she gave me had MOLD on it and she wouldn’t refund me and this was, like, right when we started trying for Jeremy so I was hormonally a mess and, again, detached garage.
ERICKA: Holy shit
ALEX: Oh my God.
MALLORY: The judge was very understanding, so we settled for damages and 2 years of parole, which is almost over, mind you.
ALEX: Oh my God.
ERICKA: I just got shot at with a felon. This was not worth getting to yell at that old cunt
ALEX/MALLORY: Language!
MALLORY: What are we going to do?
ALEX: Who’s we?
MALLORY: This was your idea.
ERICKA: What is she supposed to do, go back to freaking Deliverance over there and reason with her?
A beat
I mean, that’s actually not a terrible idea. No one saw you on the porch, and you are the most pathetic—sympathetic—of us, so you could explain that it was all a misunderstanding, clear everything up, and we’ll all pretend this never happened.
MALLORY: You can’t ask her to go over there. She could get shot!
ERICKA: And you could go to jail! And I have a record of, let’s say, less-than-friendly correspondence with Fran as it is. We all have things to lose.
ALEX: How less than friendly?
ERICKA: (muttering) I said that I would cut off her head and shit down her neck
MALLORY: What?
ERICKA: I said I would cut off her head and shit down her neck. But listen, she called no backsies when I accidentally put one of my mom’s necklaces in the box with a Vitamix she was picking up, and that was right when Mom went into the home, and she was asking about THAT specific necklace, and like… who does that? Obviously it wasn’t supposed to be with the blender.
ALEX: What goes on in this town? How am I not the most fucked up person in this group?
MALLORY: Lang—
ALEX: I swear to God.
DAN (from offstage): Everything alright in there, honey?
MALLORY/ALEX/ERICKA: Fine!
ERICKA: (quieter) The point is, me being seen “menacing” her is maybe not the best look and—what is that smell?
MALLORY: Jeremy, baby, not now.
ERICKA: No, you need to handle that. That is so disgusting
DAN and BEN enter
DAN: Hey, we heard yelling and—wow that is a stench. (Looks toward car seat, looks inside) Aww, look at this little man. What a bruiser. Do you want me to handle that for you so you girls can keep, um, yelling?
MALLORY: That really isn’t necessary
DAN: It’d be our pleasure, right, Ben?
BEN: Sure.
They exit, BEN with diaper bag and DAN with car seat/ Jeremy
ALEX: Okay, how do you want me to do this?
MALLORY: Seriously?
ERICKA: I don’t know if I feel comfortable—
ALEX: You guys have something to lose. I’m circling the drain anyway, so worst case scenario Fran finally does me a favor.
MALLORY: That is incredibly dark
ERICKA: But appreciated! Okay, so, I think, maybe, you just go over there, explain the misunderstanding, get her to talk to her neighbors, and we’re cool. Just, you know, try not to think too hard about the fact that she’s almost definitely sun-downing and maybe killed her husband
ALEX: Oh, sure, easy, yeah. What exactly makes you think—
ERICKA: You said it yourself—huge giveaways like that usually indicate that someone’s died. She’s older and pretty unstable—we’ve all seen that. I didn’t hear a man’s voice in the household, but I sure as fuck heard a gun shot. Ipso facto—this bitch killed her husband and is getting rid of all his stuff.
MALLORY: That’s a huge leap
ALEX: Yeah, I don’t know.
ERICKA: Okay, or this is all coincidence. Pick your poison. Anyway, you’ll talk to her.
ALEX: I’ll talk to her.
Several beats. Eventually
MALLORY: Um. Where do you think they took my baby?
ALEX: I mean, probably the nursery. (calling upstairs) Hun? Honey?
Nothing
Dan?
MALLORY: You don’t think he—
ERICKA: He doesn’t seem like the kidnap-the-baby type
MALLORY: He was super enthusiastic about a blowout diaper, though, and—
ALEX: Dan!
Tense stares between the three women. Eventually
MALLORY: I’m going up there. I do not need to fight a grown man for my son on top of all—
DAN and BEN enter
DAN: Were you calling for us?
ALEX/ERICKA/MALLORY: Yes!
BEN: Dan was just showing me how he’d soundproofed the nursery for, you know, sanity’s sake. Brilliant. I’m sure when you guys have your next/
DAN: Ben, maybe not right/
BEN: /I’m just saying, so smart.
DAN: Anyway, here is one freshly changed, sweet-smelling baby boy, new clothes and all.
MALLORY: Oh. Um. Thanks. We should get/
ERICKA: /I called us an Uber back to Mallory’s place, so/
MALLORY: /Good luck tonight, and uh—yeah, we’ll chat soon
MALLORY and ERICKA exit with car seat
DAN: Wait, wasn’t that our car seat?
BEN: It’s not like you guys are using it right now, so—
ALEX: I’ll get it from her tomorrow.
A beat.
BEN: Um, well, I should get going too, huh. Dan, thank you as always for your, um, guidance. Alex, a pleasure, and um…bye!
BEN exits.
DAN: What’s going on tonight that you need luck with?
ALEX: Oh, nothing. I just have to do a…thing. Hey, you know I love you, right?
DAN: That’s not ominous at all.
ALEX: No, I just mean…I know things haven’t been good for a while, but you know that you’re still my guy, right? And, like, if something happened to me, you know I would want you to be happy?
DAN: What the fuck is going on?
ALEX: Nothing, I just— (we see her decide to come clean.) So, you know Fascist Fran?
DAN: Of course.
ALEX: So, we were kind of by her house today, almost like playing a prank on her, and somehow she ended up firing at Mallory and Ericka.
DAN: Who’s Ericka again?
ALEX: The one without the baby
DAN: Okay, continue. Wait, firing?! Like with a gun?!
ALEX: Yeah. I was in the car with the baby, so don’t worry about it. But, like, also, apparently both Mallory and Ericka have records, so—
DAN: Records?
ALEX: I know, right?
DAN: I told you to join a mommy’s group, and you joined a crime syndicate?
ALEX: Don’t get me started. Anyway, because I don’t have a record and because I wasn’t seen fleeing the scene of the…well, it’s not a crime really, or if anyone committed a crime, it was Fran for shooting out a window. But still, it looked suss that they were going through her garbage, and they asked if I would facilitate a… resolution of sorts.
DAN: With a woman who just opened fire?
ALEX: When you put it like that—
DAN: What other way could you put it?
ALEX: So, that’s what’s going on. And I just wanted to make sure that, like, if something went wrong—
DAN: Well, obviously I’m going with you.
ALEX: What?
DAN: I’m not going to talk you out of this. I’m not going to sit at home worrying about you. So, did you want to drive or should I?
ALEX: Dan. Listen. I know things haven’t been great, but you don’t have to—
DAN: I do have to.
ALEX: Okay.
DAN: Alright.
ALEX: Alright.
Lights down.
ACT II
Scene 5
Porch. Huge trash bags on either side. One of the windows is shot out. ALEX and DAN approach, clearly on edge. They hold hands.
ALEX: Okay. So, I’m just going to go up there and ring the bell.
DAN: And I will…stand here uselessly
ALEX: You’re back up.
DAN: I’m a witness
ALEX: It was a very heroic sentiment
DAN: Maybe an accessory.
ALEX: A very fetching accessory.
DAN: Glad it only took the threat of your mortality for you to start flirting with me again.
ALEX: It’s been a weird year.
DAN: Well—
ALEX: Okay.
ALEX goes up the steps and moves to ring the doorbell. Before her hand lands on the buzzer, FRAN opens the door and sticks what looks like a .45 in her face.
ALEX: Shit!
FRAN: Who the fuck are you?
ALEX: I’m—
FRAN: Shut up.
ALEX: Okay.
FRAN: Are you another one of those psychopaths who’s going to decapitate me and defecate in my throat?
ALEX: Neck, but—
FRAN: Shut. Up.
ALEX nods, tries to get eyes on DAN. DAN is behind a hedge, freaking out.
FRAN: How the fuck did we get to the point where a sweet old lady who just wants to run the community swap is facing fucking death threats? What is wrong with people? And where’s your partner in crime?
ALEX: Huh?
FRAN: I know you didn’t come alone. Call them out here.
ALEX: There’s no one out there.
FRAN: Don’t fuck with me. I am not in the mood today (she pushes the gun closer)
DAN: (emerging) Hi! I think there’s been a huge, huge misunderstanding—
FRAN shoots a little to the side of DAN’s right shoulder
DAN: —Or not!
ALEX: Lady, what the fuck?
ALEX goes to grab the gun, and FRAN shoots her in the leg
DAN: Alex!
ALEX: Fucking ow! What is your problem? And this isn’t even a real gun? Seriously?
FRAN: It very much is—
ALEX: Knock it off. This is an airsoft rifle. Or, pistol, I guess. It hurts like hell.
GEORGE: (Emerging) Honey, what’s going on out here? Daniel? Hi!
DAN: (Forgetting the severity of the situation) George? Oh my God, is this your house? That is too funny! I mean, unless it messes up patient/doctor whatever, because I do NOT want to do that. Is this invasive?
GEORGE: No, not at all. I mean, I don’t think so. What are you doing here?
DAN: Oh, well, Alex here—you know Alex, or at least you know of Alex—
ALEX: Hi.
DAN: She’s a member of the freecycle group in town, and something happened with Fran
GEORGE: Oh, yeah, how rude. Franny, this is—well, actually, I don’t know if I’m supposed to introduce you to Franny. I’m still kind of unclear on all the rules and everything.
ALEX: Unclear?
GEORGE: Yeah, I mean, Daniel’s my first consistent patient. I did the coursework for my license during COVID and kind of, you know, flubbed my resume a little bit for BetterHelp, so they gave me the boot, but then I found HyperLinkShrinks, and they were totally cool about it. That’s why you get a little astericky thing before any of our Zooms, because, technically, I’m a “non-licensed counselor”, but it’s all just about, like, tests and internships and stuff. All of which is to say I feel like I read somewhere that introducing you to my partner is a no-no, but you are at my doorstep, so… Wait, why are you at my doorstep? The Facebook group?
DAN: Yeah, apparently there’s some kind of beef between my wife’s friends and Fran; and Alex was here to resolve it/try to convince Fran not to press charges, because Fran maybe kind of sort of shot at Alex’s friends earlier
FRAN: I thought they were those damn racoons going through the trash again
ALEX: Okay, but I am clearly not a racoon!
FRAN: But you were menacing me!
ALEX/DAN: I/she was NOT menacing you!
GEORGE: Franny, did you shoot this girl?
Alex gestures to her leg, which she has been holding the whole of this exchange
Franny! I told you to get rid of that thing. It’s nothing but trouble! (To DAN and ALEX) I came down for a late-night snack last week, and she got me right in the shoulder. It really hurt! And she got that thing on the stupid Facebook group too.
FRAN: You could have been a marauder!
GEORGE: What would a marauder be doing in the 21st century, Francine?
ALEX: Listen, all I wanted was for you to be cool about my friends looking through your trash—they thought it was a ton of clothes from your dead husband, who is apparently not dead.
GEORGE: No! I just Queer Eyed myself a little!
DAN: I don’t know if you’re allowed to say that.
ALEX: And they were trying to pick those up and also maybe talk to you about being less awful as a moderator, because no one is trying to mess with anyone and everybody’s going through stuff and you make the whole thing so mean-spirited. I mean, obviously I’m leaving the group and just donating stuff to Goodwill from now on, but for the other folks
FRAN: It’s a matter of social order! It’s how we got to this point in the world. You let the little things go and then all of a sudden you’re in the Fourth Reich.
ALEX: Right, but yelling at people for returning breast milk bags doesn’t fix any of that.
FRAN: It’s broken windows! It’s basic sociology.
GEORGE: Speaking of broken windows…
ALEX: Yeah, she shot that out
GEORGE: Damn it, Francine!
ALEX: Anyway, can you ask your across-the-street neighbors to just delete anything on the doorbell cameras from yesterday?
FRAN: No one in this neighborhood has those.
ALEX: I can literally see it from here,
GEORGE: That’s a fake. There was a streaking incident at last summer’s block party, and we kind of collectively agreed not to video anymore.
ALEX: Great, so I got shot for nothing.
She turns to go, then:
Fuck you, Fran. And fuck you for enabling this, George.
She limps off, with DAN turning to follow
GEORGE: Oh, um, Daniel? Nothing about this changes our work together. I think we’ve made a lot of progress.
DAN: I think I’m going to have to change therapists, George.
GEORGE: Counselors. And why?
DAN: Your wife shot my wife in the leg. I feel like that kind of changes the power dynamics a little, you know?
GEORGE: I understand. Oh, by the way, how’s the— (he mimes crying and jerking off)
DAN: Oh, that was actually a friend who just didn’t want to go to therapy.
GEORGE: (unconvinced) Oh, sure. Well, take care of yourself, Daniel. And would you be so kind as to leave the details out of your change-of-service-provider request?
DAN: Sure.
He exits
GEORGE/FRAN: Well, fuck!
Lights down.
ACT II
Scene 6
The sunroom. DAN is icing ALEX’s leg, which is in his lap.
DAN: That’s going to be an ugly bruise
ALEX: Thanks, babe.
DAN: I’m just saying, if it’s anything like paintball…
ALEX: It hurt way more than paintball.
DAN: Sorry
ALEX: It’s not your fault.
DAN: Still…
They sit for a while, in comfortable quiet. ALEX’s phone pings. She reads, then bursts out laughing.
DAN: What?
ALEX hands him the phone.
DAN/FRAN: (reading offstage) “First come first serve lightly used pellet gun with 500 cartridges. Must be 18+, pick up tonight if possible”
DAN: That is…amazing. Probably a little illegal, but amazing
ALEX: Think that was your boy’s doing?
DAN: He’s not my boy anymore. I have to request a new therapist through the app, but it takes a couple of weeks, so I guess I’ll just have to talk to you and Ben in the interim.
ALEX: And Ashlee?
DAN: I have a weird suspicion that Ashlee has Munchausen’s by Proxy. Don’t get me wrong, she totally wants to sleep with me, but I think I’m spoken for vis-à-vis erratic women.
ALEX: Awww. Thanks, babe.
DAN: This one’s pretty much melted through. I’ll go get you a fresh one.
DAN exits into the kitchen. ALEX taps on her phone a bit, then turns it off and puts it on the table behind her. DAN re-enters with fresh ice, sits back down, patting her leg gently.
ALEX: You know, I could stand to scope out the competition
DAN: Ex-pardon me?
ALEX: I’ll go to group with you next week. You’re going to need company.
DAN: You’re joking
ALEX: Nah.
DAN: Honey. That’s…thank you.
ALEX: I’m not changing my mind about anything else. We’re out of the child-rearing business.
DAN: That’s okay, you’ll…I’m glad you’re going to come with me.
ALEX: Yeah, sure.
DAN kisses the bruised area of ALEX’s leg, a little overcome. Another comfortable quiet. Eventually:
DAN: You know, if there’s anywhere else you want me to kiss to make it better.
ALEX thwacks him with a throw pillow.
ALEX: You’re an idiot.
END OF PLAY

LisaMarie Maher is a high school English teacher, adjunct professor, and occasional stage manager who holds an MFA from Columbia University in writing and a passion for exploring the absurd in writing and in theater. Her sensibility is to find comedy in all that is most painful and difficult to discuss. Her most recent play stems from the experience she had of nearly losing her infant son to respiratory illness– “Must Take All” is an exploration of how people (realistic) move beyond tragedy to keep breathing and living in an increasingly absurd world.
Share this story: